To decide whether to repair or replace a boiler, compare the repair price with a new boiler and check the age. A typical repair costs £300 including VAT, about 12% of the £2,500 a new combi costs. A repair worth more than half a new boiler, about £1,300, is a warning sign.

What a repair, a service and a new boiler cost

TypicalMost jobs
Annual service£100£70 to £150
Repair£300£120 to £600
New combi boiler£2,500£1,800 to £3,500

Typical prices including VAT at 20%. The repair is a common fault such as a pump, a valve or a sensor, and the new boiler is a like-for-like swap in a three-bed semi.

Repair or replace a boiler: when a repair makes sense

Repair it when the boiler is fairly new and the fault is small. A sensor, a thermostat or a diverter valve rarely justifies a new boiler. Check whether the boiler is still under warranty first, because the maker or installer may fix it for free.

A service costs far less than a repair and can stop one. An engineer who finds a worn part early can replace it before it fails in winter.

When to replace a boiler

Replace it when the boiler is more than ten to fifteen years old, keeps breaking down or has failed expensively. An older boiler also runs less efficiently. A new one can lower your gas bill as well as end the repair bills.

A costly part on an old boiler is the clearest case. If the engineer says the heat exchanger or the circuit board has gone, ask for a price for a new boiler on the same visit. Then you can compare the two.

Advertisement

Repair or replace a boiler: what to ask

  • How old is the boiler, and are parts still made for it?
  • What is the fault, and will the repair last?
  • What would a replacement cost, and what would it save?
  • Is the work guaranteed, and for how long?

Some households can get help with a new boiler through a means-tested scheme. The ones for your region are on our grants pages. Check before you pay a firm, because a scheme may not cover work that has already been done.

Every engineer who works on a gas boiler must be on the Gas Safe Register. Our quote checker shows whether a price is in the usual range, and boiler costs covers the other jobs in this service.