Fitting a dry verge to one gable of a typical semi costs about £900 including VAT, with most jobs between £480 and £2,000. Repointing a mortar verge costs less on the day. But mortar cracks again within a few winters, and the current British Standard for tiled roofs expects verge tiles to be mechanically fixed, so on most modern roofs a dry verge is the better buy.

What the verge does

The verge is the edge of the roof along a gable end. Its job is to hold the last row of tiles down against the wind and keep rain from blowing in under them. Traditionally that was done with a bed of mortar between the tiles and a strip of undercloak below. A dry verge does it with interlocking plastic or aluminium caps, screwed to the ends of the battens, with no mortar at all.

Why mortar verges fail

Mortar on a roof edge takes the worst of the weather. Water gets into fine cracks, freezes, and opens them up, and the sun and wind dry it out between times. After a few winters it cracks and falls out in pieces, which leaves the edge tiles loose and lets water in behind them. Falling mortar is also a hazard to anyone below.

Repointing fixes the look of it, but if the tiles have worked loose from the bed underneath, new pointing just falls out again. The lasting mortar repair means stripping and rebedding the verge, which costs much closer to a dry verge.

What the British Standard says

BS 5534, the code of practice for slating and tiling, no longer accepts mortar alone as the way to hold verge, ridge and hip tiles down. They need a mechanical fixing, such as a clip or a screw, whether or not mortar is used as well. Tile manufacturers explain the change in plain terms.

It is a code of practice rather than the law, and it does not force you to replace a verge that is sound. But a roofer rebuilding a verge today should be fixing the tiles mechanically, and a dry verge system is the simplest way to do it.

Advertisement

Dry verge and mortar verge side by side

Dry vergeMortar verge
Typical cost£900 for one gableLess to repoint, similar to rebed
MaintenanceLittle or noneRepointing every so often
In frostUnaffectedCracks and falls out over time
FixingMechanical, as the standard expectsNeeds clips or screws as well
LooksA visible plastic or metal capTraditional, and expected on period houses

When a mortar verge beats a dry verge

On a listed building or in a conservation area, the council may expect the traditional mortar finish, and a plastic verge can look wrong on a period house even where it is allowed. Some older and handmade tiles also have no dry verge system made for them. In those cases the answer is a properly rebedded mortar verge, in a suitable mix, with the tiles clipped as well.

Do the ridge at the same time

The ridge fails for the same reasons as the verge, and a dry ridge system replaces its mortar the same way. Doing both while the access is up saves paying for it twice. A typical ridge tile repair costs about £600, and a dry ridge sits towards the top of its range.

Which to choose: a dry verge or mortar

On a modern house with concrete interlocking tiles, fit a dry verge: it costs a little more than repointing, needs nothing afterwards, and meets the current standard. On a period or listed house, or with tiles no system is made for, rebed in mortar with mechanical fixings. Ask the roofer to check the batten ends while the edge is open, because rot there is common under a verge that has been letting water in. If the work goes beyond the edge, see the roofing costs and Building Regulations when re-roofing, and compare roofing quotes for the same fixings.