On a typical 20 m² flat roof, three-layer torch-on felt costs about £1,700, EPDM rubber about £2,200 and GRP fibreglass about £2,300, all including VAT. The gap between them is smaller than the gap between a good installer and a poor one, so the choice comes down to how the roof is used, how long you want to leave it alone, and who is laying it.

What EPDM, GRP and felt each cost

Per square metreTypical 20 m² roofMost jobs
Torch-on felt£84£1,700£1,200 to £2,400
EPDM rubber£110£2,200£1,400 to £3,000
GRP fibreglass£115£2,300£1,600 to £3,200

Typical prices including VAT at 20%, for stripping the old covering and laying the new one. A new deck, insulation and access move every figure up by about the same amount, whichever covering you choose.

The per-metre rate falls as the roof gets bigger, because the trims, outlet and setting up cost much the same on a porch as on a double garage. That is why a small roof often costs more per square metre than the table suggests.

How each is laid

Felt goes down in layers: an underlayer nailed or bonded to the deck, then one or two more torched on with a gas burner, finished with a mineral cap sheet. Every flat roofer can lay it, and it is quick. The flame is the drawback next to timber fascias and cladding, which is why some firms use cold-applied felt instead.

EPDM is a single sheet of synthetic rubber, glued to the deck and turned up the walls. On a garage or extension it can usually be laid with no joins at all. It needs no flame, it copes well with a deck that moves a little, and it can go down in weather that would stop the other two.

GRP is glass-fibre matting wetted out with resin on site and finished with a coloured topcoat. It sets into one hard, seamless surface, with the trims laminated in. It needs a new, firm deck and dry weather to cure, so it takes more planning and costs the most.

Advertisement

Where each is strongest

  • A detached garage or shed on a budget: felt. Cheapest, easy to patch, and any roofer can maintain it.
  • An attached garage or a single-storey extension: EPDM. Long-lasting, neat, laid without a flame next to the house, and forgiving of a timber deck that moves with the seasons.
  • A roof you walk on, or one with rooflights and awkward corners: GRP. It is hard enough for occasional foot traffic and handles complicated shapes better than a sheet.
  • A roof you want to forget about: EPDM or GRP, from an installer whose guarantee is backed by the manufacturer.

How long EPDM, GRP and felt last

Modern polymer-modified felt lasts far longer than the old oxidised felt that gave flat roofs their reputation, but it is still usually the first of the three to need replacing. EPDM and GRP, properly laid, commonly last several decades.

The covering is rarely what fails first. Most flat roof leaks start at an upstand, a trim or the outlet, or where the deck underneath has gone soft, and those come down to workmanship rather than material. A cheap EPDM roof with badly detailed edges will leak before a well-laid felt one.

Repairs

All three can be repaired, but a repair has to use the same system or one proven to bond to it. Felt is the easiest and cheapest to patch. EPDM needs the right primer and seam tape, and GRP needs a dry day for the resin. A typical flat roof repair costs about £480; the full roofing costs cover replacement. On a roof cracked or blistered across its whole surface, though, a repair only buys time and it is better to replace.

What matters more than the material

  • The deck. Every covering needs a sound, dry board underneath. If the old one is soft, it must be replaced, and only shows once the old covering is off.
  • The falls. A roof that holds puddles shortens the life of any covering. Re-covering without correcting the falls buys the same problem again.
  • Insulation. Replacing most of a roof over a heated room usually triggers Building Regulations, which means insulating it to current standards. In England and Wales a roofer on a competent person scheme can certify the work. Our guide to Building Regulations when re-roofing explains when.
  • The guarantee. Ask whether it comes from the installer alone or is backed by the manufacturer, and whether it survives the installer going out of business.

Which to choose

For most attached garages and extensions, EPDM is the best value: it costs a little more than felt and usually outlasts it comfortably. Choose GRP if you will walk on the roof or it has awkward details, and felt where the budget is tight and the building is a detached garage or outbuilding. Whatever you choose, compare quotes for the same covering, deck and insulation, or the cheapest will simply be the one that left something out.